We Would Never : A Novel

We Would Never follows Hailey Gelman, a woman caught in a storm of suspicion after her soon-to-be ex-husband Jonah is murdered. As the prime suspect, Hailey’s seemingly perfect life unravels, revealing a bitter divorce, a custody battle over their daughter Maya, and a family desperate to protect her. Her mother, Sherry, and brother, Nate, rally to her side, but their loyalty masks darker secrets and a willingness to cross lines they’d never imagined.

The novel delves into the fractured dynamics of the Marcus family, where love and control collide. Jonah’s manipulative behavior during the divorce pushes the family to their limits, exposing hidden tensions and unresolved conflicts. Meanwhile, patriarch Solomon’s secret threatens to destabilize the family’s carefully constructed facade, forcing each member to confront their true selves.

Tova Mirvis weaves a gripping tale of loyalty and betrayal, blending a murder mystery with intimate family drama. The story shifts perspectives, revealing how far each character is willing to go to protect one another—or themselves. Inspired by true events, the book explores the blurred line between right and wrong, asking how far you’d go for family.

As the investigation intensifies, alliances shift, and long-buried truths surface. The family’s desperation to shield Maya and each other leads to shocking choices, testing their morals and relationships. Mirvis’ sharp prose keeps readers guessing until the final pages, balancing suspense with deep emotional insight.

A thought-provoking exploration of love’s complexities, We Would Never challenges readers to reflect on their own boundaries. It’s a story about the lies we tell to protect those we love—and the consequences that follow when those lies spiral out of control.