The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society – C. M. Waggoner

In the quaint village of Winesap, New York, librarian Sherry Pinkwhistle has a knack for solving murders—but lately, the body count feels unnaturally high. When her boyfriend is killed and her cat, Lord Thomas Crowell, becomes possessed by a chatty ancient demon, Sherry realizes her town is trapped in a supernatural nightmare. Teaming up with the bumbling new priest and a ragtag group of friends dubbed the “Demon-Hunting Society,” she must unravel a mystery that blends cozy small-town charm with demonic forces.

The story pokes fun at classic cozy mystery tropes while diving into darker, fantastical territory. Sherry’s research skills and sharp wit are put to the test as she navigates possessed neighbors, cryptic clues, and a demon who’s oddly fond of catnip. Waggoner’s writing balances humor and horror, creating a world where Murder, She Wrote meets Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Fans of quirky characters and meta storytelling will delight in Sherry’s self-aware commentary on her own role as the town’s unofficial sleuth.

The novel’s heart lies in its eccentric cast, from the grieving widow with a secret to the sheriff who’s reluctantly pulled into the chaos. Themes of community, grief, and breaking free from toxic cycles weave through the action. Critics praise its originality, humor, and clever twists, though some note the supernatural elements may divide readers expecting a straightforward whodunit.

Waggoner’s love for genre mashups shines, blending lush descriptions of autumnal New England with demonic lore. The possessed cat, Lord Thomas, steals scenes with his sarcastic wit and insatiable appetite for treats. The final act delivers a satisfying, unpredictable resolution that leaves room for future adventures.

Perfect for readers who crave cozy mysteries with a magical punch, The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society is a love letter to book lovers and a reminder that even librarians have hidden talents—especially when demons are involved.