The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year : A Novel – Ally Carter

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year blends holiday cheer with a sharp mystery and a rivals-to-lovers romance. Maggie Chase, the “Queen of Cozy Mystery,” and Ethan Wyatt, a brooding thriller author, are invited to a secluded English estate for a Christmas party hosted by reclusive legend Eleanor Ashley. When Eleanor vanishes from a locked room during a snowstorm, Maggie and Ethan must set aside their feud to unravel the truth.

The story thrives on witty banter and escalating tension as the duo navigates a mansion full of suspects, each with secrets. Carter crafts a clever puzzle, sprinkled with nods to classic whodunits, while weaving a tender romance between two characters who challenge each other’s guarded hearts.

Set against a festive yet eerie backdrop, the novel balances laugh-out-loud moments with suspense. Maggie’s determination to prove herself as a writer mirrors Ethan’s hidden vulnerabilities, creating depth beneath the holiday sparkle. Fans of Knives Out will adore the locked-room mystery, while romance readers will swoon over the slow-burn chemistry.

Carter’s sharp dialogue and knack for pacing keep the pages turning, culminating in a satisfying reveal that ties both mystery and romance together. The book is a love letter to cozy mysteries and holiday rom-coms, perfect for readers craving a blend of intrigue and heart.